Posted on November 4, 2023 by Colleen Lynn

2023 Dog Bite Fatality: Four Arrested After Man Killed by Dog Pack, Another Severely Injured in Bienville Parish, Louisiana

Four adults were arrested after a dog pack killed one man and injured another in Bienville Parish.

Human Remains Discovered
Ringgold, LA - Four adults were arrested in connection to the death of one man and another man who sustained severe injuries. On September 27, Davyta Gray, 30, was bitten over 130 times by a dog pack on Pine Street. He underwent five surgeries and nearly died. In late October, Bienville Parish Sheriff’s investigators found human remains on Pine Street. Police later announced that one of two separate dog attacks one day apart resulted in the death of the first victim, Donovan Brooks, 40.

On October 31, police arrested four adults who live at the 2747 Pine Street property. Police believe the body of Brooks had been in a wooded area since September 26 after being moved from where he was killed by the dogs on Pine Street. Charlotte Hubbard, 77; Shawn Hubbard, 32; Gerald Miller, 51, were arrested on charges of negligent homicide and obstruction of justice. Cameron Kelly, 21, was arrested on a charge of accessory after the fact. All four people were booked into the Bienville Parish Jail.

26 dogs -- nine large dogs and 17 small, including four puppies -- were on the property when police arrived. Bienville Parish Sheriff John Ballance said deputies also found a black garbage bag in the woods containing the remains of a large dog. Brooks was last seen by his family on September 26. Brooks told a witness that day he had been bitten by the dogs a day earlier. He told the witness he was headed back to the house on Pine Street to, "'Take care of the dogs,' in his words, Ballance said.

A witness told deputies Brooks was seen that day at a store in Ringgold buying medication for wounds he said he suffered the day before from dog bites. He told the witness he was headed back to the house on Pine Street to, “’Take care of the dogs,’ in his words,” Ballance said.

Another witness said Brooks was seen on his bicycle going to Pine Street. He was dressed in clothing found with the human remains. Also recovered was a billfold with Brooks’ information in it. - KTBS, October 31, 2023

One day later, the dogs brutally attacked Gray. Bienville Parish does not have an animal control department or a facility to house stray animals. The Louisiana Radio Network reports that Ballance confirmed the large dogs involved were part pit bull. “But there were I believe nine that were part Pit and larger dogs that could easily take a human being down,” Ballance said. The social media pages of Hubbard and Miller show a lineage of past and existing pit bulls living and breeding in their home.

Multiple Double Fatalities

Two people killed by the same dogs in separate attacks is rare, but when it occurs, a dog pack is often to blame. In 2022, a pack of seven dogs attacked one day apart near Red Bay, Alabama. The first victim, Michele Sheeks, 44, died of complications weeks later. The second victim, an Alabama Public Health employee, who went to the dog owner's home to follow up, was killed during the attack. In 2014, the same pack of six pit bulls killed two men a few months apart in Lamar, Mississippi.

In 2021, the same dog pack is believed to have killed Tony Ahrens, 52, and Amber Miller, 29, a few months apart in Cocke County, Tennessee.

In 2016, a pack of five dogs killed Valente Aguirre, 58, in a dry canal in near Biola, California. After DNA testing on the five dogs proved inconclusive, the pack was returned to its owner. Three weeks later, the same pack was involved in the death of Robert Simonian, 74, who was found dead with dog bite injuries in the same canal -- at that time the canal was not dry. The cause of Simonian's death was drowning. In 2009, a pack of 16 dogs killed a senior couple hours apart in Lexington, Georgia.

In the most recent death, authorities did not learn about the first attack until after the second one (same as Mississippi case). Even if the parish did have animal control resources, the dogs could not have been seized prior to the second attack, which was not fatal. Most of the double fatality attacks that involve two separate attacks occur in the south in areas with an average population of 2,000. The inability to seize a vicious dog pack after the first fatal attack can lead to another human fatality.

Shawn & Charlotte Hubbard's Facebook pages show past and current pit bulls.

Gerald Miller's Facebook page shows multiple pit bulls and the breeding of pit bulls.

View the DogsBite.org Google Map: Louisiana Fatal Pit Bull Maulings.

Baseline reporting requirements:
Law enforcement departments across the United States should release consistent "baseline" information to the media and the public after each fatal dog mauling, including these items.

Posted on November 1, 2023 by Colleen Lynn

2023 Dog Bite Fatality: Pit Bull-Mix that Killed Child on Halloween in Northeast Spokane, Washington was Recently Adopted

Dog Adopted Out by County Shelter (SCRAPS) 8-Weeks Earlier

Colton Kline, 4, was killed by a family dog in northeast Spokane, Washington.

Dog Adopted from County
UPDATE 12/06/23: The dog that killed Colton Kline was adopted from Spokane Regional Animal Protection Service (SCRAPS) on September 2, 2023. We stated in our last update that our nonprofit already had a Freedom of Information Request into SCRAPS. We submitted the request on November 11, and it remains unanswered. A family member has since shown us the adoption receipt for a male pit bull-mix, "Spud," (Animal ID 56428) that was signed by Dustin Block on September 2.

The intake for Spud was June 9, 2023. That is 3-months before he was adopted to Block. Because our FOIA, which seeks the dog's behavior, medical and outcome records (how many times the dog was returned), remains unanswered, we know nothing about these areas. We just know that Spud was in the shelter for 3-months and was advertised at an August 6 adoption event for $28. The family member also provided a photograph of Spud seen in Block's backyard after being adopted.

Neither Spokane city or county officials released to the public that Spud was adopted to Block 8 weeks prior to the dog killing Kline. Spokane Regional Animal Protection Service (SCRAPS) now joins 16 other tax-funded shelters in the United States since 2014 that have adopted out or transferred a dog to a rescue that subsequently killed a person. The average time period between these adoptions and the fatal attack is 3-months. Our list does not include dogs placed by "fosters" or "rehomings."

Shelter Dog-Inflicted Deaths

2023 - Spokane Co. Regional Animal Protection Service (WA) - Colton Kline, 4-years old
2021 - Animal Services Center, Mesilla Valley (NM) - Avery Jackson-Dunphy, 6-years old
2021 - Wake County Animal Center (NC) - Jayden Henderson, 7-years old
2020 - Miami-Dade Animal Services (FL) - Carolyn Varanese, 84-years old
2019 - Humane Society of St. Lucie County (FL) - Christine Liquori, 52-years old
2018 - Pinellas County Animal Services (FL) - Infant Khloe Williams
2018 - The Animal Foundation (NV) - Susan Sweeney, 58-years old
2018 - Logan County Pound (WV) - Robin Conway, 64-years old
2018 - Henderson Animal Shelter (NV) - Bradley Cline, 62-years old
2017 - El Paso Animal Services (TX) - Jacob Brooks, 4-years old
2017 - New York City Animal Care Centers (NY) - Margaret Colvin, 91-years old
2017 - Kent County Animal Shelter (MI) - Infant Susannah Murray
2016 - San Diego Humane Society (CA) - Infant Sebastian Caban
2015 - Jackson-Madison County Pound (TN) - Anthony Riggs, 57-years old
2015 - Asheville Humane Society (NC) - Joshua Strother, 6-years old
2015 - Rochester Animal Services (NY) - Anthony Wind, 26-years old
2014 - Branford Animal Shelter (CT) - Rita Pepe, 93-years old

SCRAPS Forced to Euthanize Fewer

SCRAPS has a 93% placement rate, qualifying it as a "no-kill" shelter. However, "no-kill" fanatics in the city of Spokane recently targeted SCRAPS for euthanizing too many dogs. Watch the statement by SCRAPS in late September that explains why SCRAPS will not adopt out dogs with an "untreatable threat to humans and animals," and why behavior euthanasia is the most humane solution. But even with this alleged "public safety" focus, SCRAPS still adopted out a dog that promptly killed a child.

It seems clear now why neither city or county officials released to the public that Spud was adopted out 8 weeks prior to killing Kline. The attack happened in the city of Spokane, just 4-weeks after city council members voted to force SCRAPS to stop behavior euthanasia for dogs that demonstrate an "untreatable threat to humans and animals." The resolution passed says SCRAPS can only euthanize an animal that is experiencing "physical pain" and this will need a licensed veterinarian's approval.

This situation is not unique to SCRAPS (See: No-Kill Eats Their Own: When the 'Badge of Honor' to Keep Serial Biters Alive Causes Rescuers to Devour Their Own). The reality is, there are so many dangerous dogs in tax-funded shelters today, that even no-kill shelters like SCRAPS have to make more behavior euthanasia decisions than ever. These involve dogs with observable severe and/or unpredictable aggression, unlike "Spud," who did qualify for adoption, but still killed a child.

child killed by family dog in northeast spokane, washington

Spud seen in a YouTube video with his SCRAPS kennel card (Animal ID 56428).

Left: Spud advertised for adoption event. Right: Spud in Block's backyard after adoption.

11/18/23: Dog Owner Jailed; Unrelated Offense
The owner of the pit bull that killed Colton Kline on Halloween is in jail after violating a court order. Dustin Block, 48-years old, appeared in a Spokane Superior Court Friday. In May of 2021, Block was arrested for possessing child pornography and voyeurism. According to court documents, Block's girlfriend at that time, discovered hundreds of pornographic photographs and videos on Block's personal computer. Police investigators determined that 14 photographs depicted minors.

When the dog attacked, Colton was with his grandmother inside Block's home -- the two are dating. She told police that Colton would stay at the home every other week. But Block was under a no-contact order for minors. If Block had followed that order, Colton would never have been in his home. Block was released without bond and is currently awaiting trial. "Had he not been there that night, he wouldn't have been attacked by that dog, and presumably would still be alive," the prosecutor said.

While Spokane police officers were at the scene of the fatal attack, they observed Block behaving extremely intoxicated. They observed him slurring words; and he was unable to stand. Block admitted to the officers that he was drinking wine when his pit bull violently attacked Colton. Prosecutors argued that the court should impose a $50,000 bond. But the judge set the bond higher at $100,000. Block is set to go on trial for the possession of child pornography and voyeurism next month.

KHQ reports the timeline differently. According to their review of court documents (that are not viewable to the public), the thumb drive of images depicting minors was found in Block's home in 2021. The allegations of what took place in the photographs occurred in 2015 with a victim who was 15-years old at the time. Block was first given the no-contact order this summer, not in 2021. It remains unclear if Colton's grandmother, who was dating Block, was aware of the no-contact order.

The Elephant in the Room

No information about the pit bull, or how or when Block acquired it was mentioned in the KREM report. The child's father posted in a Facebook comment that the pit bull had only been in the home for two months. Currently, our nonprofit has an outstanding Freedom of Information Request into Spokane Regional Animal Protection Service (SCRAPS), who took custody of the dog's carcass after the attack, in the hopes of learning which adoption or rescue agency, if any, Block acquired this dog from.

The history of Block is horrible -- the possession of child pornography. But a message, allegedly sent from the boy's grandmother to people on social media, indicate that even after she stabbed the dog, it repeatedly attacked the boy. "One lethal bite so strong I had to slit that dog's throat with a kitchen knife for him to release my sweet baby angel," she wrote. "I could not talk to 911 and fight the dog off because even after being stabbed, his throat cut, he came back to kill my baby 3 times," she wrote.

Colton was in the home of Block, who was violating a no-contact order with minors and was intoxicated at the time -- perfect! Colton was in the home of Block, who recently obtained a pit bull, a dog breed that has killed nearly 270 children since the 1980s -- perfect! Of course, Block wouldn't want a dachshund or beagle or 300 other non-pit bull breeds. Now, Colton is dead, the dog is dead, relatives are traumatized, and Block is heading into his criminal trial set for December -- perfect!

11/01/23: Family Pit bull Kills Child
Spokane, WA - A child is dead after being attacked by a family dog. Spokane police officers responded to a residence in the 900 block of East Walton Avenue at approximately 8:00 pm Tuesday. Upon arrival, officers discovered a child suffering life-threatening injuries by the family's dog. Officers "immediately began rendering aid," states a media release issued by Public Safety Communication Manager Julie Humphreys. The dog was severely injured by family members who intervened to save the child.

Child killed in fatal dog attack

On 10-31-23, just after 8PM, SPD responded to the report of an animal attack at a residence in the 900 block of E Walton Ave. Officers arrived and discovered a small child had been attacked by the family’s dog. Officers immediately began rendering aid, and care was subsequently transferred to SFD and AMR. Despite the efforts of first responders, the child succumbed to their injuries.

Family members’ valiant attempts to protect the child resulted in the dog being severely injured and beyond help, ultimately dictating that officers euthanize the animal on scene.

At this time, there does not appear to be any criminality involved in the incident, rather it appears this was a tragic accident. This incident occurred in a residence, and was not related to trick-or-treating activity.

Information of the victim will be released by the medical examiner’s office at a later date. SCRAPS took custody of the dog’s body. - Julie Humphreys, Public Safety Communication Manager

Officers euthanized the dog at the scene. Spokane Regional Animal Protection Service (SCRAPS) took custody of the deceased dog. The medical examiner's office will release the victim's identity at a future time. Roger Hammers, who lives next-door, told KHQ that a grandmother, grandfather and a 4-year old boy live in the home with a pit bull-mix. Roger is a nurse at a nursing home and was asked by the grandfather for help. Hammers witnessed the aftermath of the attack and the child's injuries.

"It was incredibly difficult to watch that little guy fight for his life ... There was a considerable amount of blood loss." - Roger Hammers

This boy's death marks the second fatal pit bull mauling in Washington state this year. Last month, in Kennewick, 65-year old Billene Cameron died after being attacked by two pit bulls that first attacked her pug "Diego." A neighbor witnessed the attack and climbed a 6-foot fence to help. He beat one of the pit bulls with his cane, allowing Cameron to escape inside her home. The second pit bull followed her into the home and continued the attack. No charges have been filed in connection to her death.

SCRAPS confirmed to KREM (in the video footage) the dog involved was a pit bull. A GoFundMe that identifies the child as Colton Kline has been created to help the boy's family with funeral costs.

The home in the 900 block of E. Walton Avenue where a boy was killed by a family dog.

View the DogsBite.org Google State Map: Washington Fatal Pit Bull Attacks.

Posted on November 1, 2023 by Colleen Lynn

2023 Dog Bite Fatality: Man Killed by Pair of Pit Bulls at Mobile Home Park in Moncks Corner, South Carolina

Dog Owner Faces Involuntary Manslaughter Charge; Other Offenses

The Moncks Corner mobile home park where David Eller was killed by two pit bulls.

Dog Owners Charged
UPDATE 11/02/23: Berkeley County detectives charged two individuals in connection to the death of 65-year old David Eller in the Pleasant Oak Mobile Home Park off of Old Whitesville Road. Shannan Christine McCrackin, 45, of Moncks Corner, has been charged with involuntary manslaughter and two counts of dangerous animals unconfined on premises. Her partner, Kenneth Howard Swayne, 44, of Moncks Corner, has been charged with two counts of dangerous animals unconfined on premises.

On October 31, Eller was walking in the mobile home park, when two pit bulls bolted from a porch and fatally attacked him in a common area between two mobile homes. The attack was unprovoked, sheriff's officials said. He was pronounced dead at the scene. "Preliminary investigations that were conducted by detectives revealed that Eller was attacked unprovoked by two vicious pit bulls. The pit bulls were not contained properly," Berkeley County Sheriff Duane Lewis stated in a press release.

“This was a vicious attack on an unsuspecting victim, and this should have never occurred,” Sheriff Lewis stated. “If the owner of the dogs would have taken the proper responsibility for the safe keeping of the animals, the attack could have been prevented.” Involuntary manslaughter ("criminal negligence," defined as "the reckless disregard of the safety of others") is a charge in South Carolina we have seen after multiple fatal dog attacks. If convicted, McCrackin faces up to five years in prison.

moncks corner man killed by pair of pit bulls

Shannan McCrackin and Kenneth Swayne were charged after the fatal pit bull attack.

11/01/23: Sheriff's Office Press Conference
Moncks Corner, SC - A man is dead after being attacked by a pair of pit bulls yesterday afternoon. Berkely County sheriff's deputies were dispatched to Ayers Drive in the Pleasant Oak Mobile Home Park in the 1500 block of Old Whitesville Road at approximately 4:50 pm after reports of a dog attack. Berkeley County Sheriff’s Capt. Michael Crumley said a witness called 911 to report a man being attacked by two pit bulls. At the time of the attack, the man had been walking in the neighborhood.

“I believe our 911 caller was traveling down Old Whitesville Road and saw the dogs dragging around an object and turned around and then discovered that object was a human being,” Crumley said. “She did what she could to try to end the attack but there wasn’t much to be done. She did the right thing, stayed in her car, called 911.” - WCSC, Berkeley County Sheriff’s Capt. Michael Crumley

Both pit bulls were confiscated and are being held at the Berkeley County Animal Center. The victim's name has not yet been released. The coroner's office is working to notify his family. "Fortunately, here in Berkeley County, we don't get these calls too regularly," county coroner Darnell Hartwell said. "A few years ago, we had one similar to this as well, but it's definitely a tragic incident." At the scene, BCSO deputies collected evidence. Investigators interviewed witnesses and the dogs' owner.

Crumley said the attack occurred in a common area. "He was just a passerby in a common area between two mobile homes here. As he passed by, those dogs escaped off the front porch of their residence, and that is where the attack occurred in that common area," Crumley said during the press conference. The attack was "unprovoked," he said. BCSO detectives are reviewing if there were any previous complaints about these dogs. It's unclear if the dogs' owner will face any charges.

Audio dispatch log files from Berkeley County Fire and EMS state the owner is a female. "Caller is on the phone advising there are two pit bulls that are actively attacking a male ... Being advised that the owners are now out with the animals. The male [subject] is very bloody." The dispatcher said the female owner tried to get the dogs off the male subject, who sustained "extensive injuries to face and head." Prior to the arrival of Fire/EMS, responders at the scene said "the dogs have been secured."

On Wednesday, the coroner's office identified the victim as 65-year old David Eller of Moncks Corner. The coroner also attributed the man's death to a pit bull mauling. “We are having him autopsied at the Medical University tomorrow, but at this point we believe that the death is 100% contributed from the fatal attack from the pit bulls,” Hartwell said. “Our condolences goes out that family for this tragic incident that occurred on yesterday.” Investigators are determining whether any charges will be filed.

Mobile home park where a man was killed by two pit bulls in Moncks Corner, South Carolina.

View the DogsBite.org Google Map: South Carolina Fatal Pit Bull Maulings.

Posted on October 29, 2023 by Colleen Lynn

Ring Camera Video of Pit Bull Attacking Pomeranian in San Francisco Used in Vicious and Dangerous Dog Hearing

Video of pit bull attacking pomeranian is shown during the Vicious and Dangerous Dog Hearing.

Statement of Decision
San Francisco, CA - On April 25, 2023, a Vicious and Dangerous Dog Hearing was held to determine if a pit bull met the definition of "vicious and dangerous" set forth in the San Francisco Health Code. On February 28, 2023, the pit bull, "Chyna," flew out of an open garage door, grabbed a small dog by the neck, and "shook the dog for approximately five minutes," states the complaint. The pomeranian, "Bambi," did not survive her injuries. The brutal attack was captured on Ring camera video.

The 5-minute segment only shows the attack. The audio of the hour-and-a-half-long vicious dog hearing is available for download on the BSPics YouTube page in the description. Briefly, both dogs were female. Bambi, a 5-year old unspayed pomeranian, was outside for a walk with her owner to urinate that day. Bambi was not leashed. Chyna, a 7-year old spayed rescue pit bull, upwards of 50 pounds, who was "not normally aggressive," bolted from a garage and fatally attacked Bambi.

"Kuang said that on February 28, 2023, at 1:40 pm, she took her Pomeranian dog, Bambi, outside for a walk to urinate. Bambi was not spayed and weighed 18 lbs. A Pit Bull dog came out of nowhere and went straight for Bambi’s neck. Kuang, who was in shock, unsuccessfully tried to fight off the Pit Bull. Kuang ran to her garage to get a broom to try to fight off the Pit Bull. After minutes of screaming, her neighbor Michelle Sung ran out to help. Kuang lost hope but continued to hit the Pit Bull with her broom. When the owner, Ricardo Baldizon showed up, he begged them not to call the police, explaining that the dog was not normally aggressive." - Amended Statement of Decision

As you can see in the video, the attack is sudden, unprovoked and vicious. The pit bull executes the killing bite -- latching onto the dog's neck -- immediately. Then violently shakes the dog in its jaws for several minutes. As Bambi is being fatally injured and shaken, she cries out in fear and pain. Her owner grabs a broom and starts striking the pit bull with it, which does nothing to deter the pit bull. A neighbor rushes into help, and we hear both women screaming. Bambi has since stopped screaming.

"Michelle Sung, Kuang’s neighbor, testified that on February 28, 2023, at approximately 1:45 pm, she heard a dog crying in a high-pitched tone. Sung saw one dog on top of another and Kuang hitting the Pit Bull with a broom trying to get it to release Bambi. Sung tried to help by throwing rocks at the Pit Bull. Kuang froze and dropped the broom. Sung picked up the broom and struck the Pit Bull. No matter what Sung and Kuang did, the Pit Bull wagged its tail and continued pouncing on Bambi. She opined that the dog was unsocialized and did not know how to behave around other dogs.

Sung did not think the Pit Bull intended to kill Bambi. Rather, the dog enjoyed killing like a game." - Amended Statement of Decision

This pit bull certainly intended to kill the small dog, which is why the pit bull instantly executed the killing bite. There were no play bites or ear bites. The pit bull latched onto Bambi's neck, and quite possibly regripped a few times while the pit bull ferociously shook the dog in its powerful jaws until Bambi was rendered defenseless or dead. This was a classic pit bull attack. That the pit bull was wagging its tail during the vicious attack shows the dog's enjoyment of the act of fighting and killing.

"Physical and behavioral conformation mean that you cannot breed out behavior and keep the dog the same shape," Semyonova states. "Form follows function – you can’t have a dog whose entire body and brain are adapted to executing the killing bite without having, in fact, a dog who will execute the killing bite." - Alexandra Semyonova

The co-owner of Chyna, Taija Liscinsky, testified during the hearing that the sudden, unprovoked attack was an "accident," because her pit bull had "never aggressed on a dog before." Liscinsky also said that Chyna is an "emotional support dog" for her. Liscinsky and the dog's other owner, Ricardo Baldizon, said they had the locks and door handles changed to prevent Chyna from escaping in the future. Despite the vicious attack, Liscinsky characterized Chyna as a "gentle, loving senior dog."

Liscinsky was not present during the attack. Baldizon was inside their home. He ran outside barefoot and was able to pry Chyna off of Bambi. Then, according to Bambi's owner and Sung, the female neighbor who rushed to help, Baldizon begged them not to contact the police (a plea we have heard from the owner of a vicious dog too many times to count). Fortunately, Sung did report the attack to police, which resulted in an SFPD incident report and the Vicious and Dangerous Dog Hearing.

Despite Chyna's owners submitting eight letters in support of their cause, the hearing officer declared Chyna to be "vicious and dangerous for the remainder of her life," and placed restrictions on her ownership. Chyna must be leashed and muzzled when in public. Unless confined, Chyna must wear a "front attaching harness" using a leash no longer than three feet. The dog must wear a "rigid basket muzzle" and only walked in public "by responsible adults," according to the order.

The dog also has to undergo six hours of training in an effort to correct "problem behaviors" (genetic pit bull dog aggression is not correctable, but only manageable) and the owners must take steps to ensure the dog does not escape again, such as "installing self-closing hinges on the doors and installing a gate in the doorways," states the order. If Chyna is found to be off-leash or unmuzzled in the community, "ACC shall immediately seize Chyna" and another hearing will be held, states the order.

Other Parts of Testimony

We also reviewed the segment of testimony by Bambi's owner, who is assisted by a Cantonese interpreter, and Sung (starting at 14:30). In her full testimony, Sung comments further on the cruel nature of the attack, the pit bull was "playing with her like a cat and mouse," and "it wasn't just like one fatal bite," and that her own dog has been attacked by a pit bull in the past. Sung has now been affected by two acts of pit bull dog aggression outside of her volunteer work at the SF SPCA.

(20:30) "I think what was scariest is the pit bull could have killed Bambi in one bite. It's a very small fragile dog. It really was like she was playing with her like cat and mouse, and it wasn't just like one fatal bite. So Bambi died in the most cruel way possible, which is just heartbreaking for everyone..."

Regarding if she had ever had prior interactions with the dog, she said ... "My dog has been attacked by a pit bull in the past so, when I see a pit bull, I'm sure there's friendly ones, but I avoid it. So, we've never had any interactions besides that day." - Michelle Sung

Rescue Pit Bull Chyna

During the hearing, Liscinsky states that Chyna was adopted from a shelter in 2017. That shelter, "Front Street," is the city of Sacramento's shelter. Chyna was adopted out by a government shelter in one jurisdiction and became the subject of a dangerous dog hearing in another jurisdiction. Liscinsky states, "We will not deny that this situation was horrible and devastating too all parties involved. We will not say that this incident is not traumatizing. We will say this was purely an accident."

When testifying about Chyna's behavior, Liscinsky states, "We wanted to make her life easier by putting her only in situations where she was with humans." She added, "Our goal with her was to make her life happy. Animals just seemed to not do that for her." When asked by the hearing officer about Chyna's reactivity to other dogs, she described it as her dog having "uncomfortability" in outdoor situations other dogs. Chyna had never aggressed on another dog before, Liscinsky testified.

"Chyna is an anxious dog, and we wanted to make her life easier by putting her only in situations where she was with humans. A shelter dog, regardless of anything that could be perceived when meeting them, can change once you adopt them. Our goal with her was to make her life happy. Animals just seemed to not do that for her."

Hearing examiner: So, you've noticed some dog reactivity in the past?

"Not necessarily reactivity. Just uncomfortability. Not wanting to go to the park and be around dogs or anything like that, it was more of a situation where she just didn't seem comfortable and so we keep her out of those situations."

Hearing examiner: And how did her discomfort manifest itself?

"Anxiety, tucked tail. All of those factors. Not enjoying the time outside in those areas."

Hearing examiner: Has she aggressed on any dog before this incident?

"Never." - Taija Liscinsky

Summary

If Liscinsky's testimony is believable, Chyna escaped from her home on a single occasion after she was adopted in 2017. During this single occasion of escaping, the dog got through two doors -- the unit and garage doors, both doors were unsecured that day -- and fatally attacked Bambi in a wholly unprovoked attack at the "instant" this escape opportunity presented itself. Chyna is absolutely a "zero margin of error dog," which equates to being a "major liability dog" for these two young owners.