2008 Dog Bite Fatality: Henry Piotrowski, 90-Years Old, Killed by Two Pit Bulls

killed by two pit bulls staten island
Henry Piotrowsky, 90-years old, died after being brutally mauled by two pit bulls.

Mauling Victim Dies
Staten Island, NY - On July 1st, Henry Piotrowski was brutally attacked by two of his neighbor's pit bulls. Crime scene tape flowed, a LifeFlight helicopter hovered and many first responders gathered at the crime scene. Initially, Henry suffered an amputation to one leg. Within two days, it was reported that he might undergo additional amputations.

By July 13th, Henry was fighting for his life. As a World War II veteran, Henry had likely witnessed injury that most of us could not imagine. What Henry could not imagine, is that in his twilight years, he would be savagely attacked by two pit bulls because he stepped into his own backyard. By August 6th, it was reported that his eyes rarely opened, he needed a tracheotomy tube to breathe and a feeding tube for nourishment.

On August 17th, Henry Piotrowski died, 47 days after the attack.

Currently, the Piotrowski family is suing the City of New York for 7 million dollars. The suit alleges that the city failed to take appropriate and adequate measures to control the vicious dogs, despite numerous complaints from neighbors and 311 and 911 calls about the animals. The family's lawyer, Micheal Gervasi, said, "It seems to us it was a danger that was known to the city," and no measures were taken to abate the danger.


08/06/08: Family Files $7 Million Dollar Lawsuit archived
New York, NY - Lawyers for the 90-year-old Staten Island man who was mauled July 1st by two neighborhood pit bulls filed a notice of claim against the city seeking $7 million in damages. Henry Piotrowski was severely injured in the attack in his backyard, which caused the amputation of his left leg, and injury to his face, neck, arms and right leg.

Piotrowski's lawyer, Michael Gervasi of the West Brighton law firm of Russo, Scamardella & D'Amato, filed the paperwork, which is a prelude to a formal lawsuit, alleging the city "failed to take appropriate and adequate measures to control the vicious dogs," despite numerous complaints from other neighbors and 311 and 911 calls about the animals.

"It seems to us it was a danger that was known to the city," and no measures were taken to abate the danger, Gervasi said.

Piotrowski, a widowed World War II veteran, who was a vibrant and independent person before the attack, remains in critical condition in the intensive care unit at Richmond University Medical Center, West Brighton. He is barely conscious, his eyes almost never open, and he will rely on a tracheotomy tube to breathe and a feeding tube for nourishment for the rest of his life.

It was reported on December 12th, 2007 that a a jury in the Bronx paved the way for a pit bull mauling victim to receive millions of dollars against the city of New York. It's unclear how many times and at what million dollar cost the City of New York must be sued before they institute common sense laws that address their undeniable pit bull problem.


07/13/08: Politician Supports Pit Bull Ban
A 90-year old Staten Island man, who was savagely attacked by pit bulls two weeks ago while standing in hos own yard, floats in and out of consciousness as he fights for his life at Staten Island University Hospital family members say. Elaine Sutton, Henry Piotrowski's 66-year-old niece said, "They [the pit bulls] were eating him alive. It's not easy to picture."

She said her uncle lost his lower left leg and has a broken right leg. His left arm was nearly chewed off by the dogs. Doctors are still not sure whether that arm can be saved. Sutton said her uncle's plight has sparked an outpouring of support and cards from across the country. The attack, followed by the mauling of a 3-year-old Brooklyn boy, has renewed calls for a pit bull ban.

Councilman Peter Vallone Jr. (D-Queens) said, "I happen to think a ban is humane. This is the most abused breed of dogs." Vallone has been lobbying state legislators to overturn a law that bars municipalities from banning specific breeds of dogs. "Who is Albany to tell us how to protect our citizens against dangerous dogs?" Vallone has yet to gain support of the Albany lawmakers.

He does have support from PETA, one of the country's largest animal rights groups. The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA), on the other hand, also does not support Vallone. They believe that people make pit bulls bad, while they simultaneously say that pit bulls will chew through chain link fences to attack other animals among other atrocities.


07/03/08: Victim Suffers Amputations
Newspapers are now reporting that Henry Piotrowski has suffered not one, but three amputations due to the pit bull attack. DogsBite.org reminds readers that 90-year old individuals do not heal easily. The risk factor of infection for a person over 50 is highly amplified. If a person is nearly double that age, the factor must take on exponential meaning.

In one of two known medical reports about pit bull injury, doctors in Texas -- the pit bull killing capital in the US -- examined an 83-year old man that endured a "sustained attack" by two pit bulls. A sustained attack is described as an attack that lasts 15 minutes or longer. The term was derived from pit bull injury. Survivors of these attacks suffer massive tissue loss -- body regions completely degloved -- amputation, primary and secondary infections and organ failure.

The report, Pit Bull Attack: Case Report and Literature Review, was published in 1988 and has been used in court evidence to describe the unique differences pit bulls cause due to their deadly "lock and shake" bite trait. The authors write:

"Most breeds do not repeatedly bite their victims, however, a pit bull attack has been compared to a shark attack and often results in multiple bites and extensive soft-tissue loss...Pit bulls tend to inflict more serious bite wounds than do other breeds because they tend to attack the deep muscles, hold on, and shake."

This report was published twenty years ago and the analysis is just as real today. The authors detail the catastrophic wounds and surgical procedures endured by the 83-year old victim, including "meshed split-thickness skin grafts, hyperbaric oxygen therapy, oliguric renal failure (kidney failure)" and the amputation of his left arm. The victim died on the 42nd hospital day.


07/02/08 Crime Scene Tape Flows archived
Staten Island, NY - In a developing story, a 90-year-old man was mauled by two pit bulls in a brutal attack in Staten Island's Port Richmond neighborhood. The victim, Henry Piotrowski, was taken to Richmond University Medical Center in West Brighton, and is listed in critical condition. His left leg has been amputated at the knee, and he'll likely lose one of his arms as well.

His niece, Lainey Suttuon said, "We're pretty sure the [left] arm is going to go, too." Saving the left arm would require a 10-to-12-hour operation, and doctors are reluctant to submit her elderly uncle to the ordeal. Also, his right leg is fractured. "The next three days are very critical. He lost a lot of blood," said Ms. Sutton, who drove from Hillsborough, N.J., after hearing about the attack.

James McNair, 28, the dogs' owner, was arrested Tuesday night in connection with the gruesome incident, police said. The animals were put down. Charges against McNair -- a registered sex offender -- are pending. (The 11-year old child in the video lived at the dog owner's home along with a woman that denied owning the dogs and declined to comment.)

The attack occurred just after 11am on July 1st. In describing a sustained attack, neighbor Reginald Bell said that, "The dogs were actually eating him alive." Bell was drawn outside his home after he heard the victim screaming for help. He spotted the dogs on top of Piotrowski in the man's back yard. Bell said. "His legs were eaten to the bone. His arms were eaten to the bone."

Bell said he ran inside his home, called 911, then grabbed a butcher's knife and chased the dogs away from their defenseless victim. The pit bulls had fled by the time police arrived. Cops searched the neighborhood before locating the dogs inside a nearby house. More than an hour after the attack, officers were seen carrying the pit bulls, Popeye and Brutus, out of the home.

Related articles:
09/04/08: 2008 Dog Bite Fatality: Luna McDaniel, 83-Years Old, Dies from Pit Bull Injury

2008 Dog Bite Fatality: Detroit Man Killed by Stray Pit Bull Attacking Dog

robert howard, killed by a fighting pit bull in detroit
Robert Howard, estimated to be 35-years old, was killed by a fighting pit bull.

Victim Tried to Help
Detroit, MI - A Detroit man died1 Thursday after he was bitten by a reported fighting pit bull on Mack Avenue and Lakepointe Street. Police said a woman came out of her home when she saw a stray pit bull attacking her dogs. When the woman tried to stop the attack, the pit bull started coming toward her. Robert Howard came out of his house to help the woman, when the pit bull turned on him, fatally biting him in the calf. Howard's friend, Isaiah Brown, describes the attack:

      A Detroit man died Thursday after he was bitten by a fighting pit bull on Mack Avenue and Lakepointe Street.
      Police said a woman came out of her home when she saw a stray pit bull attacking her dogs.
      When the woman tried to stop the attack, the pit bull started coming toward her.
      Robert Howard came out of his house to help the woman, when the pit bull turned on him and bit him in the calf.
      "The dog had tore into his calf and when he let go, he just snatched and pulled all the arteries out. He was lying on the steps, and when I checked his vital signs he was already dead then," said Howard's friend Isaiah Brown.
      Police said the dog bit a main artery in Howard's leg and he later died of his injuries. ClickOnDetroit, August 15, 2008

Witnesses interviewed by ClickOnDetroit said that loose fighting dogs (pit bulls) are a problem in their Detroit neighborhood and believe this pit bull to be one. Yet according to the ASPCA and pit bull advocates, fighting dogs do not attack human beings. Dogfighters allegedly "culled man-biters" from their bloodlines, despite the fact that famous fighting bloodlines such as, Bolio, Chinaman, Zebo and others are widely known to encompass man-biters and man-eaters.

1Pit bull advocates often say that fatal pit bull attacks are reported more than any other fatal dog attack. This is entirely untrue. The story of Robert Howard was reported by a single media outlet. What is true is that pit bulls fatally attack more humans than all other dog breeds combined every year.

Related articles:
07/23/08: 2008 Fatality: Mississippi 3-Year Old Boy Killed by Pit Bull
06/02/08: ASPCA Pushing Pit Bull Adoption: Adopt-A-Bull Contest
01/23/08: 2008 Fatality: Kelli Chapman Killed by Two Pit Bulls

2008 Dog Bite Fatality: Tulsa Infant Killed by Labrador Puppy

mother of baby killed by dog
Linzy Earles, the mother of 2-month old boy mauled to death by family dog.

Manslaughter Charges archived
UPDATE 11/04/08: Linzy Earles, who turned 18-years old last month, has been charged with second-degree manslaughter in a juvenile court in connection with the mauling death of her baby, 2-month old Zane Alen Earles. The Tulsa police affidavit states that Zane "was left unattended in an infant swing on the opposite side of the house for approximately two hours." In this time, the family's 8-week old lab-mix,  "that was left loose in the house ate the two-month-old victim."

     Fransein’s order states that Earles was previously adjudicated as a delinquent child. A police affidavit states that Earles “has had a history of drug abuse and she was just taken off probation on June 2” in a drug-related matter.
Second-degree manslaughter involves an accusation of “culpable negligence” — an omission to do something that a reasonably careful person would do or failure to use ordinary care and caution.
“We feel that if not for her culpable negligence, it would have been prevented,” Cain said. - Bill Braun, Tulsa World, November 4, 2008

08/05/08: Neglect Charges Filed
A police affidavit alleges child neglect by the 17-year-old mother whose 2-month old son was mauled to death by a family pet. Tulsa Police allege that Linzy Earles has a history of drug abuse and was neglectful when her baby, Zane Earles, was killed by a dog at the home of his mother and grandparents on July 28. Police responded to a call about a dog mauling at the home. When officers arrived, they found the baby had been left unattended in a baby swing for about two hours.

     Investigators have been granted a warrant to test the mother's hair and take a blood sample to determine whether she was under the influence of alcohol or narcotics at the time of her son's death, and to possibly explain why "she was unable to wake up to hear her baby's screams prior to her baby's death,” according to an affidavit.
Police plan to conduct a decibel sound test in the home to find out whether any screams from the infant should have been heard when he was being attacked by the puppy, the affidavit states. Tests will be conducted inside the house to find any possible body fluids left at the scene by the puppy "tracked through the residence after eating the victim."- Johnny Johnson, The Oklahoman, August 6, 2008

07/30/08: Mother Only 17-Years Old
Authorities identified the 2-month old baby as Zane Alen Earles. Police have not released the names of his parents or his grandparents. Tulsa police spokesman Leland Ashley said the dog was taken to an animal shelter after the attack and euthanized. Ashley said the mother found her son dead in an infant swing about 10:30 am Monday. The child's body was taken to the state medical examiner's office, where the cause of death is pending, said Randy Saffell, a spokesman for the office.

      The child's father and grandfather left the home, 2904 E 102, at 8 and 8:30 a.m. Monday, Ashley said. Before the grandfather left, he put the infant in a swing in a dining room at the east end of the south Tulsa home. The infant's mother and grandmother were asleep in their bedrooms at the west end of the home.

Ashley declined to release the parents' names, but said the infant's father is 18 and the mother is 17.
Authorities think Earles was bitten numerous times by the black Labrador puppy. - Sheila Stogsdill, The Oklahoman, July 30, 2008

07/28/08: Baby Killed by Family Dog
Tulsa, OK - In a developing story, it appears another family dog has attacked and killed an infant. In this instance, the victim was a 2-month-old baby in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Police said the infant was mauled to death by a young Labrador this morning. The child died at the scene. Officer Jason Willingham says the baby's mother and grandmother were home at the time, but nobody was in the room when the attack occurred. He says the child was left in a swing.

Related stories:
07/25/08: 2008 Fatality: 1-Year Old Erie Girl Killed by Family Dog
07/23/08: 2008 Fatality: Mississippi 3-Year Old Boy Killed by Pit Bull

2008 Dog Bite Fatality: 1-Year Old Erie Girl Killed by Family Dog

Addison Sonney killed by family dog
Addison Sonney, 14-months old, was attacked and killed by her family's dog.

Family Dog Kills Child
Erie, PA - A 1-year-old girl has died after being attacked by her family dog. The Allegheny County medical examiner said Addison Sonney died yesterday at Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh. The girl's mother, Kari Sonney, was treated at a hospital for injuries suffered trying to save Addison. Police followed the dog into a nearby neighborhood and shot and killed it. The attack happened yesterday at the Laurel Hill Cemetery in Millcreek. The child's father is the cemetery caretaker.

The dog fled after the vicious attack. Millcreek police had to hunt the dog down with guns drawn. At first through dense thicket at the corner of Love and Zimmerly roads, where they shot it five times. The dog continued to flee, reports the Erie Times News, eventually into a wealthy nearby subdivision. Officers told children and people outside on the Sunday morning to go inside their home. The dog eventually took refuge on a porch on Cristina Drive, where police shot and killed it.

The dog, which police said was an old English sheepdog mix, was tracked down and shot dead by Millcreek officers.

Samples of the dog's remains have been sent to the state Department of Agriculture for rabies testing. Those results are expected today.

Addison was attacked at her family's home, the Laurel Hill Cemetery caretaker's cottage, 4523 Love Road, just after 10 a.m. Thursday. Her father, Brady Sonney, is the grounds supervisor at Laurel Hill, and the family lives in the cottage.

Addison's mother, Kari Sonney, also was injured in the attack. She was treated at Hamot Medical Center and released.

"She was trying to protect her daughter," Millcreek police Lt. Michael Tesore said of Kari Sonney.

Tesore said the two were in the home's living room when the attack occurred. He said investigators did not know what provoked the attack. - Kara Rhodes, Erie Times News, July 25, 2008

Related articles:
07/23/08: 2008 Fatality: Mississippi 3-Year Old Boy Killed by Pit Bull
06/19/08: 2008 Fatality: Boy Killed by Pit Bull in Weslaco, Texas