2023 Dog Bite Fatality: Arkansas Man Arrested After Pack of Guarding Breeds and Pit Bulls Killed his Cousin

Copperhead road kennels fatal dog mauling
James McCool died after being attacked by a dog pack at Copperhead Road Kennels.

Dog Owner Arrested
Lincoln County, AR - On January 18, a kennel owner in Star City, Arkansas was arrested after authorities said his YouTube channel shows canines he trained to "attack in a pack like manner and have a prey drive at a young age" killed his cousin last year. Scott Alan McCool, 48, was booked into the Lincoln County Detention Center on a manslaughter charge in connection to the October 29, 2023 mauling death of 39-year old James Woodrow McCool. Scott is being held on a $25,000 bond.

According to an arrest affidavit, "The pack of dogs were allowed to run free in the yard, by Scott McCool." And "witnesses state that a person or animal cannot walk into Scott's yard without Scott being around, because the dogs will attack. Due to Scott McCool' s training practices and neglect to keep his dogs contained, his dogs mauled James McCool to death." On social media, the owner goes by Sam McCool who specializes in breeding "guard dogs, American pit bull terriers" and more.

The Copperhead Road Kennels YouTube channel shows a mixture of pit bull, American bully, Belgian malinois, cane corso, presa canario, Czechoslovakian wolfdog breeds, and their crosses. He also advertises bandogs in his breeding program. The kennel also has a TikTok page. One video shows the dog pack on a porch with the voice over "security system engaged." Another shows the dog pack tearing up and eating a deer carcass. There are enough videos to keep you occupied for hours.

McCool's Facebook page has lots of gems too, including one post that points out a fully falsified pedigree from the American Bully Kennel Club. "I'm tryna figure out why somebody gonna push ABKC American Bully paperwork with a ped full of gamedogs from the 50's and 60's and it ain't even hung right (sic)," Scott wrote. One person comments, "Dave Wilson is the biggest baddest paper hanger ever lol not even surprised!" Scott seems to know the historical game-bred pedigrees quite well.

Several dogs from Copperhead Road Kennels, including "S.MCCOOL' STUMP" are listed on a pedigree game dog website. "Owned by Sam McCool favorite dog very game. Dead game!" Stump died in 2019. He was a "foundation male to many kennels," states the notes. "S.MCCOOL' HAZEL" is seen on McCool's Facebook page. Hazel is a "Grand champion OREBA," states the notes, which is a registry for protection and working bull breeds, like pit bulls, American bullies, mastiffs and bandogs.1

Information about the victim is less known. A family member posted about his death on October 29. She also commented on the KATV Facebook post. "My uncle couldn't walk, he was born with a rare medical condition that made his muscles weak and left him not able to move his legs in his late 20s. Them dogs not only killed a man, they pulled him out of his wheelchair and killed him with him unable to defend himself in any way," she wrote. Her family is "heart broken, and we absolutely want justice."

Third Case Charged in Arkansas

The criminal charges against McCool marks the third set of charges in Arkansas in connection to a 2023 fatal dog mauling. In October, Chris Scott was charged with negligent homicide after 60-year old Brenda Witt was killed by five pit bull-mix dogs in Texarkana. In August, Blytheville police charged David Veasey, 43, with two counts of felony aggravated assault and other charges after his three pit bulls mauled 93-year old Jeane Bennett in June. She died while hospitalized two months later.


Copperhead road kennels fatal dog mauling

Several dog breed lines of Scott McCool at Copperhead Road Kennels in Star City, Arkansas.2

Scott (Sam) McCool Stumpline genetics

A 2020 post by Dog Husbandry Blacklist shows that McCool believes aggression is genetic. 

1On January 21, the Orebaregistry sent us a nasty email because the pedigree website (pedigree.gamedogs.cz) contained inaccuracies, according to them. The pedigree website pages for "Stump" and "Hazel" have since been hidden by the pedigree website. We have replaced those pages with PDF files of the originals. Here's what the email said: "You people better get your information right. You morons and idiots are known liars. S.MCCOL HAZEL is registered with ADBA not with us. Get this in your small yellow bus head. You clown assuming we are with this Sam MCCOOL men. But we aren’t with him and never call his dogs Grand champion with my Club. You people better stop before I suit you." It's unclear if the same vitriol was unleashed on the SOURCE of the issue (pedigree.gamedogs.cz).
2The primary breeding lines are the "Stump" and "Hazel" pit bull working lines, as depicted in the pedigrees. The bullherders, as McCool coined them, are Belgian malinois mixed with pit bull, cane corso (and other mastiffs) and a dash of Czechoslovakian wolfdog. McCool also keeps one or more traditional purebred pit bull terriers in his "yard."
map iconView the DogsBite.org Google Map: Arkansas Fatal Pit Bull Maulings.

Related articles:
10/13/23: 2023 Dog Bite Fatality: Woman Killed by Multiple Dogs in Texarkana; Found Dead...
08/17/23: 2023 Dog Bite Fatality: Blytheville Woman Mauled by Three Pit Bulls in June Dies...


Baseline reporting requirements:
Law enforcement departments across the United States should release consistent "baseline" information to the media and the public after each fatal dog mauling, including these items.

Chilling Video Captures Pit Bull Attacking Man and His Cavapoo in Bensenville, Illinois; Victim Shares Account of the Attack

David and his cavapoo "Kali" were viciously attacked by a loose pit bull in Bensenville, Illinois.


Bensenville, IL - Just after the New Year, David, who is heard on this video trying to save the life of his dog, sent in his account of the attack that occurred on September 29, 2022. The video is chilling because of what you can hear but cannot fully see as he attempts to "extricate Kali (and later, myself) from the jaws of the pit bull." Kali suffered severe and crushing injuries in the violent attack. The only option was humane euthanasia. David said he relives parts of the horrific attack every day.


I recently finalized a settlement with the owners of a pit bull that attacked me and my 23-month old cavapoo on Sept. 29, 2022. Now that the litigation is over, I want to share my video (neighbor's doorbell camera) of that day when my dog, Kali, and I were viciously attacked, ultimately resulting in her being euthanized.

Kali suffered from hydrocephalus, a condition where spinal fluid builds up in the brain, resulting in seizures to relieve the pressure. Although we tried to regulate her condition with medications, it is difficult to say whether we were successful or not. We do know that her condition caused a great deal of developmental retardation. However, she made great strides during her time with us and was definitely loved and capable of showing affection to her family.

Because of her limited development, it was necessary, for whomever was walking her, to constantly keep interacting with her and focusing her attention on the path ahead. Therefore, I was not able to peruse my surroundings that day and the pit bull was able to dart across the street and attack us from behind before I could act to defend us.

I won't go into the details of the struggle, as they are evident from the video. However, thanks to a couple of passersby, I was finally able to extricate Kali (and later, myself) from the jaws of the pit bull. I rushed home and immediately drove Kali to our local vet. Upon examination of her wounds (her left hindquarters had been ripped open, exposing flesh and bone), it was determined that her hip had been crushed in the initial bite. Due to her condition, our vet felt that the only humane thing to do was to euthanize her, as she would not be able to withstand going under anesthesia required for the surgery (not to mention the rehabilitation).

Not a day goes by that I don't relive September 29th and wonder what I might have done differently to save our good little girl. She will forever be in our hearts, but so will the awful way her all-too-short life came to an abrupt end - at the careless hands of a pit bull owner and his animal capable of violent destruction and death.

Kali's death did inspire me to help our local village government re-write the Dangerous Animal Code. The relevant sections are in Bensenville Code Title 4, Chapter 6, Sections 4-6-1. I hope it can serve as a model for others.

Regards,
David M.

It is haunting to listen to the guttural cries during the struggle. David told us that while he held his dog "like a football" in one arm, he swung his fists at the pit bull. He punched the pit bull in the face repeatedly, but it was like "hitting a brick wall." His hand and knuckles swelled up to double the size afterward. The skin on his hand and fist peeled off after the swelling subsided. The dog also knocked him to his knees during the struggle; so his knees were scabbed up from scraping the sidewalk.

His wife and daughter also took turns walking Kali. He said it could have been either of them that day instead of himself, a thought that plagues him.

The video came from a neighbor's doorbell camera across the street from the attack. After David obtained the video, he emailed it to the Village President. He was contacted the next day to meet with the president. This is when David first faced the antiquated village code. Through the process that followed, he worked with village officials to strengthen the definitions of dangerous and vicious animals, increase penalties for dogs at large, and to prohibit the keeping of "vicious" animals.

The pit bull's owner was issued a $750 dollar citation. The man had just moved to the area. Through research, David and his wife learned this was not the dog's first offense. At the owner’s old home, his pit bull bolted into a yard and attacked a woman's small terrier. There was no major damage, but the woman made a statement to police to ensure the incident "was on the record." This provided David's case with more evidence. The owner had knowledge his dog had attacked another dog in the past.

DuPage County Animal Services (DCAS) -- the county's sole public animal shelter and control agency -- determined the pit bull to be "dangerous," which is not a death sentence in the state, but has some additional requirements, including mandatory spay/neuter. However, David was told the dog was put down a few weeks after the attack. He never saw any proof of euthanasia documents, but he hasn't seen the dog since either. The pit bull was originally from northwest Indiana, about 40 miles away.

Though his family does not walk by the former pit bull owner's home anymore, he doesn't believe the man has acquired another dog. He does believe the new village code will help future victims. But it still relies on people reporting incidents, like the owner of the terrier, to start a documented paper trail. David said that from start to finish, the process took just over a year. He added that, "closure doesn't work." It's best to move on and hold in our hearts the good memories our family had with Kali.

doorbell camera captures pit bull attacking man and cavapoo

Kali was 23-months old when she and her owner were viciously attacked by a loose pit bull.

Related articles:
01/20/21: Victim Shares Account of Vicious Pit Bull Attack on Christmas Day at Seahurst Park...

Why Were They There?

In Memory of My Aunt Jill: She was Killed in a Savage Dog Attack

Jill peterson - why were they there
Jill Peterson was killed by a pack of vicious dogs in her own backyard in 2019.

Pall Mall, TN - Bessie "Jill" Peterson, 88-years old, was savagely killed by a pack of dogs belonging to her neighbor on February 26, 2019. Her sister, Nina Brown, witnessed part of the violent attack. Jill had gone into her backyard to clear a drainage ditch. The pack of six mixed-breed dogs came from behind and attacked her. "They dragged her down the yard and all of her clothes were off, her shoes, everything. They tore all of her hair out, the casket can't be open, it's like a nightmare," Brown said.

Family members said that Nina, who was 85-years old then, never recovered emotionally from the horrific attack and what followed. The first grand jury issued a No Bill. The second grand jury indicted on two felony counts. The owner, 62-year-old Holly Evans Delk, later entered a plea to one count, allowing dogs to run at large resulting in death. She was sentenced to three years probation. Nina died on August 27, 2023. A relative wrote a poem about what happened to her Aunt Jill that day.


Why Were They There?

We hear your screams,
you were all alone.
Being torn apart,
flesh and bone.

You looked around,
no dogs in sight.
You stepped outside,
into the light.

You stepped outside,
to give seed to the birds.

You looked again,
no dogs in sight.

The recent rain
had been a pain.
The ditch was clogged,
it needed to drain.

You let down your guard.
You stepped from your porch,
into your yard.

They attacked without warning,
no snarls, no growls.
You were their prey,
on that horrible day.

You were scared.
You knew they were fierce.
We hear your screams,
with every pierce.

Why were they there?
Didn't anyone care?

The owner, she knew.
The Sheriff did too.

Six of them
bit, ripped and tore.
You fought for your life,
that would be no more.

Your sister came home,
she looked all around.
She found you,
face down on the ground.

She tried to help.
They came after her.

Why were they there?
Didn't anyone care?

You were here for 88 years.
We'll never forget you,
through all of our tears.

It's just so unfair.
Why were they there?
Didn't anyone care?

You were cold,
as you took your last breath.
No one should suffer,
such a brutal death.

We hear your screams,
as you fought for your life.
We hear your screams,
all day and all night.
💜💜💜💜💜
We love you.
We miss you.
We wish you were here.

Jill peterson - why were they there

From left: In memory of Jill (Brown) Peterson and her sister, Nina Mae Brown.

Related articles:
09/10/19: 2019 Dog Bite Fatality: Elderly Woman Mauled by Pack of Dogs in Pickett County Dies

Coroner: Dead Before Mauling - Man Found Dead Could be Result of Dog Pack Attack in Big Spring, Texas

Big Spring police suspect that Jasson Bullard, 40-years old, was killed by a loose dog pack.


Post-Mortem Bites
UPDATE 01/08/24: Preliminary autopsy findings indicate that Jasson Bullard, 40, died of pulmonary emphysema with bullae formation, a chronic lung condition, and that animal predation occurred post-mortem. Bullard's death marks the second high profile case in 2023 where post-mortem predation (bite damage) occurred. Bullard's body was exposed in an outdoor location, the Howard County Fairgrounds. The other victim's body, Carol Streit, 65, had been exposed in an outdoor vacant field.


12/21/23: Dogs Suspected in Death
Big Spring, TX - A man found dead Tuesday showed signs of "animal predation," according to the Big Spring Police Department. Officers responded to a call of a deceased person at the Howard County Fairgrounds in the 2900 block of Old State Hwy 80 at about 8:45 am on December 19. A pack of dogs was seen running from the area where the body was found. An autopsy is expected to be performed today. Animal control officers already captured two of the dogs believed to be involved in his death.

NewsWest 9 examines the stray dog problem in the area. They interviewed a resident, who said that "animal control is full, they can't handle anymore." That's why the dogs are roaming around. "The animal control people are swamped." The news agency also identified the victim as 40-year old Jasson Bollard. In 2021, a 46-year old man was killed by a pit bull in the city. Neighbors who witnessed the deadly attack, said the pit bull dragged the man up and down the sidewalk before police arrived.


From Big Spring Police Dept (KBest Media):

12/19/2023

On the 19th of December 2023 at approximately 8:45 A.M., Big Spring Police Department officers were sent to the Howard County Fair Grounds property located in the 2900 block of Old Hwy 80 due to a deceased White/Male individual. Upon arrival officers found a group of dogs run from the area in which the male subject was found. The preliminary investigation has not determined any cause of death though the deceased has evidence of animal predation. An autopsy has been ordered by the Justice of the Peace and is scheduled for 21st of December 2023. The identity of the deceased has been found to be Jasson Bullard 40 years of age. Next of kin has been notified.

Big Spring Animal Control has taken measures to identify, locate and seize two of the dogs involved in this incident.

This is an ongoing investigation, and no further information is available at this time.

Chief of Police, Chad Williams, Administrative Lieutenant Brian Gordon

dog pack kills man in big spring Texas

A man found dead at a fairgrounds property may have been killed by a dog pack.

Related articles:
05/11/21: 2021 Dog Bite Fatality: Man, 46, Killed by Pit Bull in Big Spring, Texas


Baseline reporting requirements:
Law enforcement departments across the United States should release consistent "baseline" information to the media and the public after each fatal dog mauling, including these items.