2009 Dog Bite Fatality: Rancho Mirage Man Killed by Two Mastiff Dogs

Fiancée Contests Mauling
UPDATE 04/02/09: New information has been revealed about the death of Williams. On March 26th, it was reported that William's fiancée, Anna Tucker, is contesting how he died. Tucker says that authorities have it all wrong. She said it's likely that Williams was suffering from a heart condition and the dogs were only trying to help him. "I don't believe that my dogs did it," Tucker said. "I think they were trying to help him. They knew something was wrong."

She never meant to have the dogs euthanized either. Tucker said she did not understand the paperwork she signed.

Tucker said she was unaware that Williams had an enlarged heart until the autopsy was completed. Williams had scratches on his arms that "were kind of deep," and bite marks on his ankles, but "there was nothing on his chest, neck and face," Tucker said, contesting the mauling claims. "The bites on his ankles wouldn't have caused his death." Tucker said she returned home with her 8-year-old daughter and found Williams' body in the house.

A similar "contesting" occurred after Ving Rhames' mastiffs attacked his gardener. Rhames' dogs were ultimately vindicated.

Initial reports said that Williams' was the owner of the dogs. And according to Sgt. Dennis Gutierrez, a neighbor of Williams' called the police and reported that he was bleeding profusely in his backyard. Responding deputies found the body and two large dogs in the backyard. A person, referred to only as a "friend," told news reporters that he was the first person at the scene and he reported that Williams had "severe wounds on his forearms."

Tucker also said that her dogs were Italian mastiffs, not bullmastiffs (the Neapolitan and Cane Corso are both Italian mastiffs). We've been speculating on the dog breeds involved as well. Given that the breed was stated as "some kind of bullmastiff mix," we wondered, mixed with what? Our research pointed to the black dog being a "bandog" (also called a bandogge or Swinford). The bandog is an unofficial breed that is comprised of 50% pit bull and 50% mastiff.

The Italian mastiff (Cane Corso) makes a lot more sense than a bullmastiff. Additionally, the investigation into Rhames' dogs took 5 months to complete.

03/17/09: Victim: Hill Andrew Williams
An autopsy confirmed that two large dogs were responsible for killing their 38-year-old owner in Rancho Mirage Monday night. Riverside County Sheriff's officials said Hill Andrew Williams died of "significant physical trauma" he suffered in the attack. Williams was found near death in his backyard Monday afternoon at the rear of his home. Animal Services Behaviorist Jackie Schart said each dog was "some sort of bullmastiff-mix."

03/17/09: Dogs Surrendered and Euthanized
Riverside County Animal Services reports that the bullmastiffs involved in the attack were signed over by the victim's girlfriend and euthanized today. The dogs were being held at the Coachella Valley Animal Campus in Thousand Palms. Officers were told the victim may have been trying to breed the dogs. The male, named Butter, was 3-years old and weighed about 115 pounds. The female, Ebony, was about 2-years old and weighed about 90 pounds.

An autopsy is scheduled today. The victim's name was not released.

03/16/09: Details Slim; Emerging Story
Rancho Mirage, CA- In a developing story, Riverside County may be faced with another fatal dog attack in less than 3 months. Back in December, 60-year old Gerald Adelman was savagely attacked by his family's two pit bulls while he took a "smoke break" in his back yard. Riverside County Sheriff's Department spokesman Dennis Gutierrez said that investigators arrived at the Rancho Mirage scene at 5:15pm today and found a dead man and "two large bullmastiffs."

Related articles:
12/20/08: A Recent Review of California Fatal Dog Attacks (2006-2008)
12/20/08: 2008 Fatality: 2 Pit Bulls Attack, Kill 60-Year-Old Rubidoux Man

Wichita Approves New Ordinance: Mandatory Sterilization of Pit Bulls

Breeders Also Targeted
Wichita, KA - It was announced today that Wichita City Council approved changes to its animal ordinance. The changes are set to go into effect July 1st. The updated ordinance targets pit bull owners, but all Wichita dog and cat owners will be affected. New requirements for pit bull owners and breeders include (view new ordinance):

  • Mandatory microchipping of pit bulls
  • Mandatory sterilization of pit bulls (unless owner obtains breeder’s license)
  • Households are limited to two pit bulls (exempts owners with valid permits prior to new ordinance)
  • Provides right to appeal determination that any dog is a pit bull and allows vets to certify that the dog is not a pit bull.
  • Exempts pit bulls kept temporarily in city for legitimate dog shows and service dogs.
  • Breeder’s license will allow no more than two unaltered adult pit bulls.
  • Breeder’s license cannot be issued for residential premises.

In addition to new pit bull requirements, the city wants to allow more flexibility for rabies vaccinations. Animals would be required to get rabies shots every three years instead of annually. It also includes new animal nuisance provisions, zoning requirements for commercial animal businesses (dog groomers) and rules and regulations for off-leash dog parks.

Wichita now joins many other Kansas cities which have implemented pit bull laws including: Arkansas City, Dodge City, El Dorado, Lola, Junction City, Kansas City, Leawood, Maize, Manhattan, Overland Park, Park City, Pittsburg, Prairie Village, Roeland Park, Salina, Shawnee County, Spring Hill, Sterling, Topeka, and Ulyssess. View all related Kansas ordinances.

Related articles:
03/06/09: Two New Cities Ban Pit Bulls: Pilot Grove, Missouri and Gallipolis, Ohio
02/10/09: Fort Drum Prohibits Aggressive Dog Breeds from Base Housing
02/06/09: Ecuador Joins International Trend: Bans Pit Bulls and Rottweilers as Pets
01/28/09: Lancaster Passes Mandatory Pit Bull and Rottweiler Sterilization Law

Two New Cities Ban Pit Bulls: Pilot Grove, Missouri and Gallipolis, Ohio

Vicious Dogs Unwanted
Pilot Grove, MO - It was reported this week that the City of Pilot Grove banned 5 breeds of dogs. Dogs prohibited under Ordinance No. 42 include pit bulls, chinesischer kampfhunds (German for Sharp-Pei, which is a Chinese fighting dog, see translation), chows, dobermans and rottweilers. The ordinance states the breeds were chosen because these breeds "have shown a sufficient propensity of viciousness or ability to inflict serious injury such."

Pilot Grove now joins a number of other Missouri cities with pit bull and dangerous breed laws including: Cameron, Chillicothe, Clayton, Fayette, Ferguson, Florissant, Independence, Jennings, Kirksville, Liberty, Springfield, Sikeston and Wentzville. View all related Missouri ordinances.

It was also reported this week that the City of Gallipolis, Ohio passed an ordinance banning pit bulls. The ban also extends to mixed breed dogs that contain pit bull, and "vicious dogs" that have, without provocation, killed or caused serious injury to a person, or have killed another dog. The ban arose after a 13-year-old girl was seriously injured by two pit bulls in January. Officers had to shoot both dogs dead in order to get them to release the girl.

Gallipolis now joins a number of other Ohio cities that ban pit bull type dogs including: Bexley, Cincinnati, Garfield Heights, Girard, Greenhills, Lakewood, Reynoldsburg, Village of South Point, Warrensville Heights, Wooster and Youngstown. View all related Ohio ordinances.

Related articles:
02/10/09: Fort Drum Prohibits Aggressive Dog Breeds from Base Housing
02/06/09: Ecuador Joins International Trend: Bans Pit Bulls and Rottweilers as Pets
01/28/09: Associated Press Comments on the Many U.S. Cities Proposing Pit Bull Laws
01/19/09: More U.S. Cities Proposing Pit Bull Regulations

2009 Dog Bite Fatality: Police Officer Couple's Infant Killed by Family Dog

Chow Kills 2-Week Old
Mesa, AZ - On Wednesday, the mother of a 2-week old baby girl -- who is a police officer with the Salt River Pima Maricopa Indian Community -- stepped away from her baby momentarily to use the bathroom. She had left the baby in a low-lying bassinet or crib. When she returned, she discovered the family dog, a chow (or a chow-mix), had severely bitten the infant. By the time Mesa paramedics arrived the baby was unresponsive and pronounced dead on the scene.

Detective Steve Berry of the Mesa Police Department said this story hits especially close to home because the baby's father is a Mesa police officer. He was on duty at the time of the deadly attack. It's not known how long the family had had the dog, which was euthanized Thursday. Two other dogs were taken from the home by a man who knows the family, but it's unclear if the dogs belong to them. So far, Mesa police do not believe anyone to be at fault in the infant's mauling death.

Related articles:
01/21/09: 2009 Fatality: Olivia Rozek, 3-Weeks Old, Killed by Family Husky
09/25/09: 2008 Fatality: 3-Day Old Infant Killed by Family Dog