Tuesday, June 30, 2009
From left: Gabrial Mandrell, views of the front of the home and yard.
UPDATE 06/30/09: The three dogs involved in Gabrial's death have been euthanized: two pit bull-mixes and a collie-mix. Police said in a previous statement it is believed the collie-mix was tied up during the incident while the pit bulls were loose. In a press release issued Tuesday by the Williamson County Sheriff's Department, it stated that "Gabrial suffered at least one bite that would have made 'yelling impossible,'" whereby eliminating possible child neglect charges.
The release also stated the attack "might have been triggered by a stuffed animal that was found in the yard," which is perhaps the most alarming distortion DogsBite.org has ever run across. "Normal" family dogs do not attack and kill children because the child may be holding a stuffed animal. Pit bulls, on the other hand, will attack and kill unpredictably and unprovoked as documented by multiple fatality studies (See also: Triggers: What Prompts a Pit Bull to Attack?).
To highlight the questionable issues raised by the press release, we have included part of the article below. The tragic death of Gabrial and subsequent investigation also demonstrates two important issues often seen in serious and fatal attacks: 1) The possible protection of parents after the attack because the parents have already suffered a terrible loss. 2) And, at what point will, "Our pit bull never showed aggression before" become an inexcusable legal defense?
"The couple had three dogs, two pit bull mixes and a collie mix. Police said in a previous statement it is believed the collie mix was tied up during the incident while the pit bulls were loose.06/29/09: DCFS Opens Investigation
Cundiff said the child was attacked about 200 feet from the home and crawled from the window, which was at the opposite side of the house as the adults' bedroom. The release went on to state that Gabrial suffered at least one bite that would have made "yelling impossible."
"The residence didn't have air conditioning," Cundiff said in a news release issued Tuesday. "Numerous box fans running at the same time of the incident would have made it very hard for the adults in the house to hear anything outside."
Sweeney and Robinson requested all three dogs be euthanized the night of the attack, but the lead detectives called for the animals to be held at Williamson County Animal Control shelter until the investigation was complete.
In a release Tuesday, Cundiff said the attack might have been triggered by a stuffed animal that was found in the yard.
"It appears Gabrial brought the stuffed animal out with him when he left his bedroom through his open window," the release stated.
Cundiff said the family told detectives no aggression "had ever been shown to any family member from any of the three dogs."
However, Amy Fowler, a neighbor, said the pit bulls were often loose and were a nuisance, threatening members of her family in their yard. Fowler said she witnessed Gabrial playing with the collie several times, outside and unsupervised. She said the collie mix didn't seem to cause any problems."
The Illinois Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) has launched an investigation into Gabrial's death. Spokesperson Kendall Marlow said it isn’t the first time the state has been in contact with the boy's mother, although prior investigations were not related to animals and involved another child. Back in January, the DCFS was criticized after placing Alex Angul into a home with "known" dangerous rottweilers that subsequently killed the child.
06/29/09: Death Ruled "Accidental"
Johnston City, IL - Williamson County authorities say that on Saturday, June 27, 3-year old Gabrial Reese Mandrell was asleep, then woke up and "pushed out the screen" in his bedroom window. The child then "crawled out the window," and was attacked by at least one of the family's 3 dogs. The injured boy was found 200 feet away from his home and was pronounced dead shortly thereafter. An autopsy confirmed that Gabrial died due to multiple dog bites.
A collie-mix and two pit bull-mixes, which had been loose outside, were taken from the home.
01/14/09: 2009 Fatality: Alex Angulo, 4-Years Old Mauled to Death by Family Rottweiler
12/03/08: 2008 Fatality: 2-Year Old Boy Killed in Clark County, Nevada
09/18/08: 2008 Fatality: Pit Bulls Fatally Maul 4-Month Old in Las Vegas
08/04/08: Triggers: What Prompts a Pit Bull to Attack?
| 7/01/2009 9:14 PM |
While it is certainly appropriate to be sympathetic to the family of this dead child (as stated by the sheriff), it is also appropriate to look into the circumstances of the horrific death. Pit bulls attacking children, adults, the elderly, household pets, and livestock make the news daily, why were the pit bulls loose and the collie mix tied up? Why were the concerns of the neighbor regarding the frequently loose pit bulls not addressed? It is unfortunate, but it appears that the mother of this child allowed him to be placed in a very dangerous situation. The excuse about the toy is absurd, when was the last time a poodle or a beagle killed a human for a toy?
| 7/02/2009 1:48 PM |
Plaintiff PAP found that the mother had two dog ordinance violations in 1991: DOG AT LARGE/CHASING KIDS and DOG AT LARGE (DOG BITE)
| 7/02/2009 5:33 PM |
Where is the outcry from the collie lobby about this collie mix being unfairly euthanized along with the two pits that were at large? Why didn't anyone step forth and steal the collie mix from the humane society, ferreting it to an unknown location so it could live its life as it deserves?
Oh, wait, there is no "collie lobby", because collies don't routinely go berserk and maul and kill people, and collie owners aren't misanthropes and sociopaths who put dog life before human life.
| 7/02/2009 10:13 PM |
And pit bull people DON'T CARE about the sweet collie mixes getting euthanized.
Instead we are supposed to spend millions warehousing and rehabbing pit bulls, while wonderful dogs die.
That is the pit bull lobby/No Kill/Best Friends way.
| 7/02/2009 10:43 PM |
This story is so truly disturbing. The whole LOT OF IT, from the police statement to the parents...I can't understand why any Child and Family protection agency would allow a child in a home with pit bulls or rottweilers. These organizations MUST learn about the terrible safety records of these dogs. Not to mention, these very dog owners were already ZINGED by animal control. These types of dog owners need to be on the radar of Child and Family protection agencies.
| 12/05/2011 12:00 AM |
How is it not child neglect when the child was left with the 2 lawn monsters? re: it stated that "Gabrial suffered at least one bite that would have made 'yelling impossible,'" whereby eliminating possible child neglect charges.