Friday, March 7, 2014
Lawyered Up in Paterson
UPDATE 03/07/14: All sides are lawyered up following a dog mauling that injured one teenager and left another dead. It is believed the bullmastiff owned by Paul Clarke jumped out of its fenced yard and attacked the boys at about 4 pm last Friday. At some point after, shortly or hours later, the same dog attacked its owner. Animal control officers arrived at Clarke's home at about 10 pm and found the large dog nearly stabbed to death. Clarke has thus far refused to speak to police.
"Mr. Clarke has not once called the Paterson Police Department, has avoided any and all attempts by the Detective Bureau to communicate with him, and has now hired a lawyer that has directed him to not communicate with the Paterson Police Department,” Rodriguez said.Funeral services for 13-year old Kenneth Santillan were held on Thursday in nearby Totowa.
“Taking this into consideration I am left wondering how Mr. Clark and/or his lawyer are arriving at the conclusion Mr. Clark has not done anything wrong,” Rodriguez concluded. - Paterson Press
03/02/14: Mauling Victim Identified archived
Law enforcement officials identified the victim of the fatal dog mauling as 13-year old Kenneth Santillan of Paterson. Police also confirmed that the owner of the bullmastiff, named "Trigger" that attacked three people killing one on Friday afternoon, is 50-year old Paul Clarke also of Paterson. A follow up article from the Star-Ledger, "Dog that killed Paterson teen was a ticking time bomb, neighbors say," includes new allegations about the attacking dog, as well as owner neglect.
Clarke's wife Sharon admitted to The New York Post on Saturday that the dog had once bitten her son's friend. A resident who lives near Clarke, Dilma Monasterio, said that she has called police twice in the recent past about the bullmastiff, "because it would often vault fences in its own yard and in neighbors’ yards, including her own," states the article. She said that she was terrified of the animal because it often barked and acted in what she perceived a threatening manner.
This is in addition to comments by retired police officer Randy Billie who said the dog scaled the fence and attacked a teenager last year.The Ledger article also sheds some light on the 7-hour time frame. Family and friends searched the neighborhood looking for the missing teen, "throughout the night," according to authorities. "They could not locate him," said Chief Assistant Passaic County Prosecutor Michael DeMarco. "They contacted the Paterson Police, which began an investigation into the missing teen." Many parts of the timeline, however, remain unclear, including when the animal attacked Clarke.
03/01/14: Body Found in Woods
In a horrifying update, it was revealed that both boys were attacked near the dog owner's home Friday afternoon. The two boys then ran in opposite directions. One survived and the other died a miserable death all alone. The second boy was found dead 7-hours after the attack in the woods near a creek behind the dog owner's home. That teen left a trail of blood through the woods in the snow, the bloody trail is how first responders were able to find the boy, according to authorities.
Critical questions remained unanswered Saturday evening, including: At what time was the dog owner attacked? Did he see one or both teenagers being attacked? Why did the surviving teenager tell the residents who tried to help him NOT to call 911? Did the dog owner threaten him in some way, just like the dog owner did in the landmark case, Tracey v. Solesky? Police had to cut and roll back an iron fence to find the dead boy. How did the injured boy get to this location?
Finally, exactly why did it take 7-hours for first responders to locate the dead teenager?
03/01/14: More Details Emerge in Mauling archived
The original Star-Ledger news report was updated at 4:27 pm (EST) with many new details, including the time of the attack, which occurred on Friday. The injured 13-year old boy was discovered dead just before midnight by a search and rescue team. Paterson's animal control officer, John DeCando, said the male dog weighed 115 lbs and was stabbed several times by its owner -- who was also bitten badly by the animal -- before being put down by animal control.
A retired Paterson police officer, Randy Billie, lives around the corner from the dog. Billie told the Star-Ledger the dog has hopped its fence before and attacked children. Last year, Billie said the animal attacked a teenager on Sherwood Avenue. "It's nothing to play with. It's like a miniature horse," Billie said. No one appears yet to be questioning why the bullmastiff was still in the neighborhood at all? (At least prosecutors can easily prove prior knowledge of viciousness.)
There continue to be time discrepancies. The attack on the two boys occurred as early as 4:00 pm Friday. That's when the surviving boy was seen terrified and bleeding from his left hand. Residents Orlando Cepeda and his wife Carmen Baez saw the teen, helped to dress his wound and asked if they should call 911. The teen told them not to. Baez said the boy did not tell her about a second person attacked by the dog at that time and did not know anyone had died until Saturday morning.
03/01/14: Dog Kills Teenager, Injures Another archived
Paterson, NJ - In a developing story, a 13-year old boy was killed Saturday after a bullmastiff broke loose from its home and brutally attacked two teenagers near the Passaic River. Passaic County Assistant Prosecutor Michael DeMarco said the two young victims were attacked in the area of Rossiter and Crosby avenues early Saturday morning. The dog, described as a bullmastiff, attacked both children in the street after breaking free from a nearby residence, DeMarco said.
One of the victims, a 13-year old boy, died in the attack. A second teenager was able to escape with his life. DeMarco said that child, also 13, was being treated at St. Joseph's Medical Center in Paterson; the child's injuries were not disclosed. An animal control officer "put the dog down," DeMarco said. The owner of the dog has been identified. There was no relationship between the victims and the owner of the dog, according to prosecutors. Criminal charges are pending.
The Star-Ledger noted that this is the second horrific dog mauling in the area recently that left a child grievously injured or dead. In February, a 10-year old Newark boy was nearly killed by his father's two pit bulls inside a city apartment. Neighbor Robert Ricks kicked in the apartment door to save the child. "It was horrific," Hicks said. The boy was so badly injured, at one point he had "no pulse," police said. He was transported to University Hospital with life-threatening injuries.
01/03/14: 2013 Dog Bite Fatality: Woman, 75, Killed by Bullmastiff in Arkansas Gated Community
06/13/13: 2013 Dog Bite Fatality: Child Temporarily Staying with Aunt Killed by Neighbor's Dog
Photos: Paterson Press and Facebook.com
Please donate to support our work
DogsBite.org is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt public charity organization. Learn more »
| 3/01/2014 2:33 PM |
This has been a horrible week.
I am skeptical in these attacks when they are not attributed to a pit bull.
Without photos I assume its a pit bull or pit bull mix.
Even if its really a bullmastiff they came from bulldogs so it really is one and the same.
My prayers go out to the families of these boys.
| 3/01/2014 3:31 PM |
We are still waiting on more information/clarity (the news is continually updating). One article did say it was 115 pounds and it also attacked the owner, who began stabbing it...
An adolescent boy died after being attacked by a 115-pound dog and two others were wounded Friday, according to the city’s chief animal control officer. The dog’s owner, who was treated for bite wounds, stabbed the dog “quite a few times,” animal control officer John DeCando said. The dog, described as a bullmastiff...
| 3/01/2014 3:44 PM |
The deaths are coming fast and furious. Every time I read another story like this I can't help but wonder, what's it going to take for regular people to stand up and say ENOUGH! No more pit bulls! We don't believe the advocates!!!
| 3/01/2014 4:40 PM |
"The surviving teen was taken to St. Joseph’s Medical Center for a bite to his arm, family lawyer Adam Rothenberg said. “It’s a horrendous situation,” Rothenberg told The Post. “My client fled for his life.”
| 3/01/2014 7:09 PM |
According to the breed standard, the 'bull mastiff' is 40% 'bulldog'. They don't mean the wheezing Winston Churchill type that chokes on its own tongue and can hardly walk. They mean the good old fashioned fighting bulldog that we now call pit bull.
No matter the kennel club paper shuffles, this is a pit bull mix.
The same goes if they try to call it a 'presa Canario' or a 'cane Corso' or 'dogue de Bordeaux' or any of the other names they've thought up for mastiff / pit bull mixes. It's time to stop falling for their fictive name games and call it what it is, call these 'dogs' what they really are.
| 3/01/2014 9:31 PM |
This attack horrifically mirrors the attack on Scotty Mason and Dominic Solesky. Those boys were 10-years old, coming up the alley when the pit bull first jumped out of its pen and attacked Scotty. If you recall, pit bull owner Thomas O'Halloran (who was later charged and convicted of reckless endangerment) put the dog back in the pen then threaten the bloody and bitten Scotty not to tell anyone. He shoved Scotty out his front door, which was a busy street. Scotty walked home alone, terrified. Minutes later, the pit bull jumped out its pen again and attacked Dominic who was coming up the alley, nearly killing him. These two 13-year old boys were apparently walking home from school when the monster bullmastiff easily scaled the crappy fence and attacked. This is where the two stories diverge. Scotty and Dominic were playing with a group of boys; others in the group were able to alert adults soon after Dominic was attacked. The surviving 13-year old in this case was scared out of his mind, trying to get home. But why did he tell the people trying to help him NOT TO CALL 911? WHY DID HE NOT MENTION THAT HIS BEST FRIEND WAS ALSO ATTACKED BY THE DOG?
| 3/02/2014 8:39 AM |
My best uniformed guess as to why the boy didn't mention his friend, or want to call 911 is this: He didn't realize that his friend didn't get away.
In the pre-pit bull world, a dog bite was not really 911 worthy. Many people still live in this world thanks to the lies that spew forth from the mouths of pit nutters. He may have felt that it was their fault and he would get in trouble if he raised a ruckus. I was bit by a dog (a normal dog) when I was about this age, and I remember being ashamed, even though I had done nothing wrong. Also, he was just 13 and had been scared out of his wits. I think he just wanted to go home and call his friend. 13 is very young to be expected to deal with such a traumatic event in exactly just the right way. You don't expect to be attacked by a monster when you're walking home in your own neighborhood.
| 3/02/2014 4:46 PM |
I stated exactly that -- "The surviving 13-year old in this case was scared out of his mind, trying to get home." That's what Scotty did too. This does not change that shadier elements of the dog's owner might have been involved.
| 3/02/2014 9:47 PM |
Heart-rending details in this story, and more to come. The sad trail through the snow is very touching. Precious few excuses here, from anyone. So many KNEW this beast was highly dangerous; some attempted to do something about that, whilst others did nothing. However, the buck stops with the owner of the creature. He knew full well what it had done in the past and what it was capable of. The end result, the death of this poor boy, is down to the toxic and deadly relationship between him and his Fighting Breed based dog. Did he EVER think this story would have a happy ending, with a monster like that under his 'care'? Welcome to Fighting Breed ownership REALITY - ugly, brutal, in constant denial, obstinate, lacking in public spirit, intolerant of the safety of others, blinded by some misguided attachment to one of the most dangerous types of dog in the world. And who pays the price? An innocent boy.
| 3/03/2014 11:37 PM |
More news on the 4 dogs in NZ that attacked the little girl ..."Police have confirmed the four dogs involved in the attack were Staffordshire bull terrier crosses. Earlier reports said the animals were bull mastiff-type dogs."
| 3/06/2014 8:31 PM |
On Thursday, a lawyer representing Kenneth’s family, Nancy Lucianna, said that Kenneth had “extensive wounds on his body” and a broken arm. “This young man was in every sense of the word mauled to death,” Lucianna said.