Wednesday, July 6, 2011
UPDATE 07/06/11: Later this same day, another update was made to the Oregonian story. Just before the incident, the boy was being held by Louisa Farmer, Michael's maternal grandmother, while she sat on the couch. After Michael began squirming, she placed him on the floor. He then "ran across the room to Duncan," according to Michael Farmer. The dog responded by knocking the boy down and attacking him and three adults who intervened.
Two issues about this update: 1.) An 11-12 month old child does not have the coordination to run as Michael Farmer's statement suggests. While it may have been an unintentional use of the word "run" on his part, instead of a more descriptive term, such as "he quickly staggered toward the animal," running directly toward a dog indicates provocation -- the child asked for it. 2.) The dog wasn't given away at Michael's birth, his parents were the only owners.
The ramifications of the latter are significant. Michael and the dog were not new to one another. The dog attacked and killed the boy in an off-property environment while his parents were absent and he was under the supervision of his grandparents. In the 6-year period from 2005 through 2010, 12% (22) of all fatal dog attacks (182) reflected a similar scenario. In contrast, 14% (25) involved chained dogs, which is commonly known as a high risk factor.
07/06/11: Who Owned the Dog?
KOIN reports in a follow up video that after Michael was born, his parents "gave the dog to his grandparents." The segment does not specify which set of grandparents -- maternal or paternal. Sheriff Anderson states in the video: "The grandparents and the parents and everybody who was there obviously did not believe this dog was of any threat to the child." Except that upon the boy's birth, the parents removed the 135 pound dog from their home?
Separately, Lynne Terry of the Oregonian updated her original story with new details and several statements from Portland-based Jacqui Neilson, a veterinarian and animal behaviorist. Echoing other science whores, Neilson states in the newer article that only 10 fatal dog attacks are reported annually in the United States. The twenty plus more people who are killed by dogs each year apparently never had real lives, families or memorials marking their deaths.
07/05/11: Victim: Michael Naglee
Nehalem, OR - On Saturday, another child's life came to an end due to a pit bull-type dog. Press members are now identifying the animal as an American bulldog even though its breed standard, Scott-type, is by definition a pit bull-mix. At the time of the attack, the boy was at the home of his paternal grandparents, Betty and Robert Naglee. When Michael tried to squirm out of Betty's arms, she placed him on the floor. As soon as she did, the dog attacked.
The toddler was rushed to Tillamook County General Hospital, where three of the adults were also treated for injuries. Michael's parents, James and Michelle Naglee, were not in the home at the time of the incident. According to Todd Anderson, Tillamook County Sheriff, the large pit bull-type dog belonged to the boy's parents. The couple got the animal at a shelter about four years ago. The dog, named Duncan, was shot dead on scene by responding deputies.
07/01/11: 2011 Fatality: "Loving Dog" Kills Visiting Baby in Chesterfield County
04/26/11: Blogger Dissects Deceptive Online Pit Bull Identification Test, 'Find the Pit Bull'
02/24/10: 2010 Fatality: 3-Year Old Mauled to Death by Pit Bull Type Dog in Ocala
09/05/09: 2009 Fatality: 2 Pit Bulls Kill 10-Year Old Boy in Rusk County, Texas
07/26/09: History Channel Airs Segment of Double Fatal Attack; Images of Dogs Shown
Please donate to support our work
DogsBite.org is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt public charity organization. Learn more »
| 7/05/2011 6:18 PM |
We are highlighting a comment left by a "sick" misogynist who run rampant throughout the pit bull community.
lillyann said on July 5, 2011 at 1:18 PM
So very sad. My question is: could the baby did something to the dog? I have a 2 year old neighbor who pulls the ears and tail of her dog. It is a small dog though but it could turn on her. The dog had to be KILLED in the house. I would be moving, knowing my beloved pet was killed there. No thank you. It is a sad story for all involved.
| 7/06/2011 6:12 AM |
American Bulldog DBRFs 2005 to Present
Violet Serenity Haaker
3-years old | Ocala, FL
February 20, 2010
Killed at her mother’s breeding operation, that produced dogs with champion hog dog pedigrees all over the south.
Kathleen Jeanette Doyle
90 years old | Phoenix, AZ
July 26, 2009
Neighbor’s American “Pit” Bulldog
56-years old | Livingston, MI
September 13, 2007
Neighbor’s 4 American Pit-Bulldogs
91-years old | Livingston, MI
September 13, 2007
Neighbor’s 4 American Pit-Bulldogs
4-years old | Phoenix, AZ
November 5, 2007
American Bulldog that had been adopted 3 months earlier and passed multiple temperment tests
Boyd W. Fiscus
83-years old | Morgan County, IN
July 1, 2005
American bulldogs (2), Mastiff
| 7/06/2011 9:06 AM |
Amazing, lillyann completely missed a point she made, the neighbors dog hasn't harmed the 2 year old despite the child causing it some aggrivation. That dog obviously wasn't bred with a fight reflex that can suddenly erupt. If the small dog did "turn" then in all likelyhood it would nip the child, maybe even draw some blood and cause a lot of crying, but the dog wouldn't require the police to shoot it inside the home because it stayed aggitated and the baby would be very much alive.
| 7/06/2011 2:58 PM |
When I was young I often cared for a terrier type dog and we played a lot. I'd flop them on their back and we'd rough house like the boys we were.
The dog was very adamant however to not let me poke his stubby tail or try to grab it. He would not bark or lunge, but he would carefully push my hand aside with his nose and give a small poof. That was his only aggravation.
I cared for the dog periodically for at least four years. If I had tried that with a pit type dog I'm sure I would have been dead.
| 7/06/2011 3:00 PM |
I also find it amazing that this lillyann person prioritized the dog who was rightfully killed for killing a human baby. These kinds of people should be banned from deciding laws and regulation.
| 10/10/2011 6:59 PM |
I was visiting a friend that has an American Bulldog. The dog growled at me several times and snapped at me once. I thought little of that until reading some things on this site. I was lucky. Aggression is a prelude to a bite, or worse. I won't be visiting there again.